Gravity
Are Cancellation Fees Legal?
Yes — cancellation and early-termination fees are legal when they're clearly disclosed in a contract you agreed to, which is why gyms, phone carriers, and some annual plans can charge them. What's not legal is a hidden or undisclosed fee, or one that penalizes you for leaving a subscription sold as easy to cancel. Most app-store subscriptions carry no cancellation fee at all.
In most cases, yes. A cancellation fee — often called an early-termination fee (ETF) — is enforceable when it's spelled out in a contract you agreed to and reflects a reasonable estimate of the company's costs rather than an arbitrary penalty. That's why gym memberships, phone and internet plans, and some annual subscriptions can legally charge one. Fees that are hidden, never disclosed, or unreasonably large can be challenged as unfair or unenforceable, and several states cap or ban them for specific contracts like health clubs.
Most app-store subscriptions carry no cancellation fee at all. With Apple (Settings > [your name] > Subscriptions) or Google Play, you simply cancel and keep access until the end of the period you already paid for — most monthly plans aren't prorated, so you aren't refunded for unused days, but you also aren't charged extra to leave. Deleting the app does not cancel the subscription, and replacing or letting a card expire doesn't reliably stop the charges, because card networks run 'account updater' services that pass your new card number to merchants.
On the regulatory side, the FTC finalized a 'click-to-cancel' rule in 2024 requiring easy cancellation and clear disclosure of all terms and fees before billing, but a federal appeals court vacated the rule in mid-2025 on procedural grounds. Even so, undisclosed fees and deceptive auto-renewal billing remain illegal under the FTC Act and ROSCA, and state auto-renewal laws (such as California's) still require companies to disclose fees clearly and honor cancellations.
Canceling a normal subscription does not hurt your credit. The narrow exception is an unpaid balance — for example, an outstanding gym or contract fee — that the company sends to a collections agency, which can then land on your credit report. Note too that a chargeback or bank dispute reverses a charge but does not cancel the subscription or contract; to actually stop billing you must cancel through the merchant or app store, and for bank ACH payments you can also revoke authorization with both the company and your bank.
Source: https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/rules/negative-option-rule
Related questions
Can a company charge a fee just for canceling?
Only if the fee was clearly disclosed in the terms you agreed to. A surprise fee that was never disclosed — or one meant to punish you for leaving a subscription sold as easy to cancel — can be an unfair or deceptive practice. Most monthly app subscriptions have no cancellation fee; you keep access until the paid period ends.
Are gym early-termination fees legal?
Generally yes, because they're written into the membership contract. But many states regulate health-club agreements and let you cancel — often without a fee — for reasons like moving a long distance, disability, or death. Check your state's health-club statute and the contract you signed.
If I dispute the fee with my bank, does that cancel the subscription?
No. A chargeback reverses a single charge but does not cancel the subscription or contract, so the company can keep billing you and may still pursue the fee. Cancel directly through the merchant or app store, then dispute any charge that continues.
Gravity
Track renewals before the next surprise charge.
Gravity helps you track subscription renewals, monitor free trials, and keep a clean list of what still needs attention.